| INDULGENCES |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
| If you ever have a question about what you read at IAmOnetruth, please Email me at:: webmaster@iamonetruth.com |
| For a FREE Trifold on: Eucharist Unity of Christians |
| Indulgence: means that by the remission of the temporal punishments for sin, remaining after the reception of the Sacrament of Penance, the last effects of sin are removed. Contrition and confession is demanded as a condition for the fruitful reception of an indulgence. Again, an Indulgence is not a mere remission of canonical punishments, but a remission of the temporal punishments for sin imposed by God. |
The word Indulgence originally meant kindness or favor; in post-classic Latin it came
to mean the remission of a tax or debt. In Roman Law and in the Vulgate of the Old
Testament (Is., lxi, 1) it was used to express release from captivity or punishment. In
theological language also the word is sometimes employed in its primary sense, to
signify the kindness and mercy of God.
An indulgence is understood to be the remission of the temporal punishments of sin
remaining after the forgiveness of the guilt of sin through the Sacrament of Penance.
It is granted to the living by way of absolution and to the dead by way of intercession.
Remission is not a forgiveness of sin, but it presupposes as a necessary precondition
that the sin has been forgiven.
to mean the remission of a tax or debt. In Roman Law and in the Vulgate of the Old
Testament (Is., lxi, 1) it was used to express release from captivity or punishment. In
theological language also the word is sometimes employed in its primary sense, to
signify the kindness and mercy of God.
An indulgence is understood to be the remission of the temporal punishments of sin
remaining after the forgiveness of the guilt of sin through the Sacrament of Penance.
It is granted to the living by way of absolution and to the dead by way of intercession.
Remission is not a forgiveness of sin, but it presupposes as a necessary precondition
that the sin has been forgiven.
Sin is an offense against God. For the violation of God's Law the sinner incurs a penalty. In
the Sacrament of Penance, with sincere intent to repentance, the sin is forgiven, their is
remission of guilt, which means restoration of the sinner to God's friendship and in
consequence the remission of the eternal chastisement due to sin.
An Indulgence is an impossibility unless a sinner has repented and has the will to reform his
ways. After the guilt and eternal punishment have been lifted there remains the temporal
punishment due to a sin against God, which must be suffered either here or hereafter. It is
satisfied here by penance, good works done voluntarily, alms - deeds, and by patience and
resignation in the trials of life. It is satisfied for hereafter by the suffering of Purgatory.
Sacred Scripture gives us an example of what is meant by "temporal punishment."
Mary, the sister of Moses, was forgiven by God for complaining against her brother.
Nevertheless, despite such forgiveness, God imposed upon her the temporal punishment of
leprosy and seven days exile from her people (Numbers 12) [READ].
King David knows that even when God forgives our sin there is still a penalty or debt to pay.
In 2 Samuel 12:13-14 we read: "David said to Nathan, 'I have sinned against the Lord.'
Nathan answered David, 'The Lord on His part has forgiven your sin: you shall not die. But
since you have utterly spurned the Lord by this deed, the child born to you must surely die.'"
God forgave the guilt of David's sin, but He still required reparation in the form of suffering.
A thief may be forgiven for stealing a large sum of money from someone, but he is still
required to return the money taken and even do time in prison.
In the early ages of the Church it was not unusual to assign public penance's for sins. These
established penance's were called canonical because they were in accordance with the
canon or the rule of the Church. These penance's were for various periods of duration, thirty
days, a year, or several years. In some rare cases they were lifelong.
(Let me add here an explanation of some aspect of Indulgences. An Indulgence, say of a
year, does not mean a year less in Purgatory, but the remission of a chastisement equivalent
to that which was remitted in earlier times when a public penance of a year was remitted by
Indulgence. Indulgences are classified, therefore, in terms of former canonical penance.
Rather than "duration" God may relieve our stay in Purgatory by "intensity").
Penance - Public: The penitential discipline of the early Church, relaxed before the 11th
century, in respect of notorious or grave sinners, especially idolaters, murderers and
adulterers. The lifting of the penalty of excommunication and admission to the ranks of the
penitents was for long a privilege not easily to be obtained. In certain parts of the Church
such penitents were marshaled into four degrees, through each of which they normally had to
pass, namely, weepers, who were excluded from divine service asking those going in to pray
for them; hearers, who attended the Liturgy of the catechumens (then left with them),
kneelers, who knelt or lay down in the Sanctuary and participated with the Church in specific
prayers for them before being blessed by the Bishop and dismissed prior to the Eucharist.
Standers, who sat in the congregation and stayed for the liturgy of the Eucharist but did not
receive Communion. Such penance with attendant austerities ... sometimes lasted for life; in
any case it was imposed for a period of years; the terms (years and days) in which
indulgences are now granted bear reference to this practice.
The Church's Power to Grant Indulgence:
The Church possesses the power to grant Indulgences. (De fide.) [FCD] P. 5, If a baptized
person deliberately denies or doubts a dogma properly so-called, he is guilty of the sin of
heresy (CIC 1325, Par. 2), and automatically becomes subject to the punishment of
excommunication (CIC 2314, Par. I).
Pope Leo X in the Indulgence Decretal [...] (1518), bases the Church's power to grant
Indulgences on the power of the keys. Thus not every possessor of the power to forgive sins
also possesses the power to grant Indulgences. The power to lift the temporal punishments
for sins is not automatically included in the power to absolve from the guilt of sins and their
eternal punishment. By its very nature an Indulgence is not a pure act of grace, in which the
temporal punishment for sin is remitted without anything being done in return: it implies
compensation drawn from the treasury amassed by Christ and the Saints. The Bishops of the
Christian communion are entitled to distribute this spiritual treasure among the faithful. This
possibility of satisfaction derives from the unity of the Mystical Body of Christ, the Communion
of Saints.
The power to give Indulgences rests both on the power of jurisdiction residing in the Church
hierarchy and on the union of the faithful in the Communion of the Saints.
The modern form of Indulgence developed in the 11th century. It emerged from the
extra-sacramental absolutions of the early Middle Ages, in which the Pope, the bishops and
the priests, frequently invoking the power of binding and loosing transferred to them,
besought the mercy of God for individual persons or for the faithful generally with a view to
the forgiveness of their sins. When in the 11th century, the forgiveness of sins which people
hoped to be granted by God began to be imputed to the penance imposed by the Church,
absolution began to be regarded as an Indulgence.
Even in Christian antiquity the Church exercised, in a different form, the power to grant
Indulgences. In response to the intercessory appeals (Letters of Peace) of the Martyrs, the
Church especially the Church of north Africa in the 3rd century (St. Cyprian), granted to
individual penitents in specific cases, a partial remission of the penitential punishments
imposed. People confidently expected that God would remit to them the remainder of the
punishments for sins on the intercession and for the sake of the merits of the Martyrs. [...]
That our Lord has given the Church the power of granting indulgences is implied in Scripture:
"I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and whatever you bind on earth will be
bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven" (Mt. 16:19). We
notice that limit is placed on this power of loosing, "the power of the keys" as it is called. (FCD)
St. Paul provides a clear example of the Church using this power with respect to the
incestuous Corinthian upon whom he had imposed a severe penance. After learning
of the Corinthian's fervent sorrow, St. Paul absolved him of the penance which he had
imposed, saying: "For, what I have pardoned, if I have pardoned anything, for your
sakes have I done it in the person of Christ" [2 Corinthians 2:10] [Douai]
In this example we have the elements of a true Indulgence:
(1) a penance (temporal punishment) imposed on the Corinthian by St. Paul [1
Corinthians 5:1-5];
(2) sorrow on the part of the sinner for his crime [2 Corinthians 2:5-7];3)
(3) the relaxation of the penance by St. Paul (the Indulgence) [2 Corinthians 2:10a];
(4) the relaxation done in the "person of Christ" [2 Corinthians 2:10b].
Source of Indulgences
The source of Indulgences is the Church's treasury of satisfaction which consists of the
superabundant satisfactions of Christ and of the Saints. (Sent certa.) (FCD)
God could remit the sins of mankind without any satisfaction and without violating justice. But,
in fact, in the order of the grace established by God through Christ, all forgiveness of sins is
granted in virtue of corresponding satisfaction. In the extra-sacramental satisfaction of the
remission of temporal punishments for sins in Indulgences, the Church offers to the Divine
Justice a substitute satisfaction - that is, the infinite satisfaction of Christ and the
superabundant satisfaction of the Saints. These satisfactions, in the case of the Saints,
exceeded the measure of their own sins and, together with the superabundant merits of
Christ, form the Church's treasury of merit, or treasury of satisfaction.
In the granting of an Indulgence, the Church appeals to the mercy of God, beseeching Him to
grant those members of the Mystical Body of Christ who fulfill the prescribed conditions, a
remission of their due punishments which have not yet been atoned for, in the virtue of the
superabundant satisfactions of Christ and the Saints. The prayer of the Church requires the
gracious acceptance of God, but in view of the position of the person granting the Indulgence
in the Mystical Body of Christ, a hearing can, with moral certainty, be counted on. [...]
Catholics believe that many of the faithful throughout the centuries - virgins, martyrs,
confessors, saints etc. - have performed penance's and good works far in excess of what was
due as temporal punishment for their own sins. Their merits, in union with the infinite merits of
Jesus Christ, form a "spiritual treasury" which the Church can draw upon to assist other
members of the Church in general or, in particular, pay the debt of temporal punishment both
for the living and the dead:
"I am now rejoicing in my sufferings for your sake, and in my flesh I am completing what is
lacking in Christ's afflictions for the sake of his body, that is, the church" (Col. 1:24); "For just
as the body is one and has many members, and all the members of the body, though many,
are one body, so it is with Christ;... If one member suffers, all suffer together with it; if one
member is honored, all rejoice together with it" (1 Cor. 12:12-26).
Every sin "harms" not only our relationship with God but also, our relationship with other
members of the "Body of Christ". Just as every good deed "honors" or "improves" the "Body
of Christ". Once we are forgiven by God, we are put back into a right relationship with Him, but
we still need to "heal" the "injury" to the "Body' of Believers. Therefore, by virtue of the
Communion of Saints the faithful can assist each other with their prayers, masses, almsgiving
to remit temporal punishment due in purgatory. Think of the life of someone like Padre Pio, a
man who might have never committed a serious sin, living a life of penance and suffering. All
these graces are in the treasury of the Church. "Strictly speaking, isolated prayer, or any
other activity, does not exist for the Christian, in so far as he can do or suffer nothing without
reference to other Christians;... every deed of each member affects for good or ill the whole
body,..." (FCD)
What is lacking in Christ's suffering?
Our complete will! Christ as Himself, lacks nothing. But as head of the Mystical Body of the
Church, what is lacking in His suffering is our complete will in union with His will! We are part
of the Mystical Body of Christ and as such, we need to be in complete accord with Christ, in
order to complete what is lacking in the sufferings of Christ. (Monsignor Harold F. Jordan)
Bearers of the Power of indulgence:
The practice of the power of Indulgence is not an act of the power of the priesthood, but of
the power of jurisdiction. The Pope, as possessor of the Supreme Power of Jurisdiction over
the whole Church, has an absolute, that is, an unlimited power of Indulgence. The bishops, by
virtue of their ordinary power, can grant Indulgences only to those subject to them, and within
the limited compass which is regulated by Canon Law. Cf. CIC 912, 274 n. 2, 349, Par. 2 n. 2.
Even Cardinals have only a limited power to grant Indulgences. CIC 239, Par. I n. 24.
The technical meaning of the word "grant'', when there is question of an Indulgence
applicable to the faithful departed, is that the Indulgence is offered to God by way of suffrage
and appeal.
An Indulgence cannot be gained for another living person. (FCD)
Division of Indulgences
Full is Plenary - Partial is - just that part of the remittance of punishment.
a.) According to the extent of the remission of the Punishment, Indulgences are divided into
Plenary Indulgences [...], and Partial Indulgences [...], according as the temporal punishments
are completely or only partially remitted. The measure of the remission of the punishment
depends on the approval of the Church: [...]. The periods of time customarily stipulated in the
case of Partial Indulgences signify that as many punishments for sins are remitted as would
have been expiated in the given time according to the norms of the old canonical penance. [...]
b.) According to the mode of their application, a division is made between Indulgences for the
living and for the dead. The granting of an Indulgence to the living faithful is accomplished by
absolution [...]. The Church has no jurisdiction over the dead in Purgatory; thus, Indulgences
cannot be applied directly to them through absolution, but only indirectly through intercession
[...], for which reason their operation is uncertain. The possibility of their application is
founded on the Communion of Saints. [...]
Historically it was only in the second half of the fifteenth century [...], that Indulgences for the
dead appear, although the Scholastic Theologians [13th century], had already affirmed the
possibility of Indulgences for the dead (suppl. 71, 10). (FCD)
[2 Mac. 12] v. 42, "and they turned to prayer, beseeching that the sin which had been
committed might be wholly blotted out." v. 43, "He also took up a collection, . . . , and sent it to
Jerusalem for a sin offering. . . .taking account the resurrection. v. 44, For if he were not
expecting those who had fallen to rise again, it would have been superfluous and foolish to
pray for the dead."
Here we have the basic idea of our present day "indulgence" for the souls in Purgatory.
First: we know that the souls are in an intermediate state because in hell there is no relief
[Dan. 12:2; Mt. 18:8] and in heaven there is no need for relief.
Second: we have intercessory prayer for the dead & a "collection" with the intent of the relief
of suffering for our dearly departed.
Communion of Saints -
Jesus said that he is the true vine, and we are the branches. When a Christian (one branch)
dies physically and is taken up into heaven (he might have to go through Purgatory first), he
isn't broken off the vine. He remains in Christ (Romans 8:38-39). The deceased Christian is
still united with the vine (Jesus) and with all the other branches (all other Christians, living or
dead). This communion of saints makes possible the sharing of spiritual things with other
Christians.
Bibliography
All Scripture is quoted from the Revised Standard Version - Catholic Edition - Ignatius Press,
unless otherwise noted.
Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, by Ludwig Ott, (FCD). The Doctrine of Indulgences
These are sources where I was unable to verify the "authority" of the teaching. For example:
many times I used an Internet source, that did not give references as to the source of their
teaching.
the Sacrament of Penance, with sincere intent to repentance, the sin is forgiven, their is
remission of guilt, which means restoration of the sinner to God's friendship and in
consequence the remission of the eternal chastisement due to sin.
An Indulgence is an impossibility unless a sinner has repented and has the will to reform his
ways. After the guilt and eternal punishment have been lifted there remains the temporal
punishment due to a sin against God, which must be suffered either here or hereafter. It is
satisfied here by penance, good works done voluntarily, alms - deeds, and by patience and
resignation in the trials of life. It is satisfied for hereafter by the suffering of Purgatory.
Sacred Scripture gives us an example of what is meant by "temporal punishment."
Mary, the sister of Moses, was forgiven by God for complaining against her brother.
Nevertheless, despite such forgiveness, God imposed upon her the temporal punishment of
leprosy and seven days exile from her people (Numbers 12) [READ].
King David knows that even when God forgives our sin there is still a penalty or debt to pay.
In 2 Samuel 12:13-14 we read: "David said to Nathan, 'I have sinned against the Lord.'
Nathan answered David, 'The Lord on His part has forgiven your sin: you shall not die. But
since you have utterly spurned the Lord by this deed, the child born to you must surely die.'"
God forgave the guilt of David's sin, but He still required reparation in the form of suffering.
A thief may be forgiven for stealing a large sum of money from someone, but he is still
required to return the money taken and even do time in prison.
In the early ages of the Church it was not unusual to assign public penance's for sins. These
established penance's were called canonical because they were in accordance with the
canon or the rule of the Church. These penance's were for various periods of duration, thirty
days, a year, or several years. In some rare cases they were lifelong.
(Let me add here an explanation of some aspect of Indulgences. An Indulgence, say of a
year, does not mean a year less in Purgatory, but the remission of a chastisement equivalent
to that which was remitted in earlier times when a public penance of a year was remitted by
Indulgence. Indulgences are classified, therefore, in terms of former canonical penance.
Rather than "duration" God may relieve our stay in Purgatory by "intensity").
Penance - Public: The penitential discipline of the early Church, relaxed before the 11th
century, in respect of notorious or grave sinners, especially idolaters, murderers and
adulterers. The lifting of the penalty of excommunication and admission to the ranks of the
penitents was for long a privilege not easily to be obtained. In certain parts of the Church
such penitents were marshaled into four degrees, through each of which they normally had to
pass, namely, weepers, who were excluded from divine service asking those going in to pray
for them; hearers, who attended the Liturgy of the catechumens (then left with them),
kneelers, who knelt or lay down in the Sanctuary and participated with the Church in specific
prayers for them before being blessed by the Bishop and dismissed prior to the Eucharist.
Standers, who sat in the congregation and stayed for the liturgy of the Eucharist but did not
receive Communion. Such penance with attendant austerities ... sometimes lasted for life; in
any case it was imposed for a period of years; the terms (years and days) in which
indulgences are now granted bear reference to this practice.
The Church's Power to Grant Indulgence:
The Church possesses the power to grant Indulgences. (De fide.) [FCD] P. 5, If a baptized
person deliberately denies or doubts a dogma properly so-called, he is guilty of the sin of
heresy (CIC 1325, Par. 2), and automatically becomes subject to the punishment of
excommunication (CIC 2314, Par. I).
Pope Leo X in the Indulgence Decretal [...] (1518), bases the Church's power to grant
Indulgences on the power of the keys. Thus not every possessor of the power to forgive sins
also possesses the power to grant Indulgences. The power to lift the temporal punishments
for sins is not automatically included in the power to absolve from the guilt of sins and their
eternal punishment. By its very nature an Indulgence is not a pure act of grace, in which the
temporal punishment for sin is remitted without anything being done in return: it implies
compensation drawn from the treasury amassed by Christ and the Saints. The Bishops of the
Christian communion are entitled to distribute this spiritual treasure among the faithful. This
possibility of satisfaction derives from the unity of the Mystical Body of Christ, the Communion
of Saints.
The power to give Indulgences rests both on the power of jurisdiction residing in the Church
hierarchy and on the union of the faithful in the Communion of the Saints.
The modern form of Indulgence developed in the 11th century. It emerged from the
extra-sacramental absolutions of the early Middle Ages, in which the Pope, the bishops and
the priests, frequently invoking the power of binding and loosing transferred to them,
besought the mercy of God for individual persons or for the faithful generally with a view to
the forgiveness of their sins. When in the 11th century, the forgiveness of sins which people
hoped to be granted by God began to be imputed to the penance imposed by the Church,
absolution began to be regarded as an Indulgence.
Even in Christian antiquity the Church exercised, in a different form, the power to grant
Indulgences. In response to the intercessory appeals (Letters of Peace) of the Martyrs, the
Church especially the Church of north Africa in the 3rd century (St. Cyprian), granted to
individual penitents in specific cases, a partial remission of the penitential punishments
imposed. People confidently expected that God would remit to them the remainder of the
punishments for sins on the intercession and for the sake of the merits of the Martyrs. [...]
That our Lord has given the Church the power of granting indulgences is implied in Scripture:
"I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and whatever you bind on earth will be
bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven" (Mt. 16:19). We
notice that limit is placed on this power of loosing, "the power of the keys" as it is called. (FCD)
St. Paul provides a clear example of the Church using this power with respect to the
incestuous Corinthian upon whom he had imposed a severe penance. After learning
of the Corinthian's fervent sorrow, St. Paul absolved him of the penance which he had
imposed, saying: "For, what I have pardoned, if I have pardoned anything, for your
sakes have I done it in the person of Christ" [2 Corinthians 2:10] [Douai]
In this example we have the elements of a true Indulgence:
(1) a penance (temporal punishment) imposed on the Corinthian by St. Paul [1
Corinthians 5:1-5];
(2) sorrow on the part of the sinner for his crime [2 Corinthians 2:5-7];3)
(3) the relaxation of the penance by St. Paul (the Indulgence) [2 Corinthians 2:10a];
(4) the relaxation done in the "person of Christ" [2 Corinthians 2:10b].
Source of Indulgences
The source of Indulgences is the Church's treasury of satisfaction which consists of the
superabundant satisfactions of Christ and of the Saints. (Sent certa.) (FCD)
God could remit the sins of mankind without any satisfaction and without violating justice. But,
in fact, in the order of the grace established by God through Christ, all forgiveness of sins is
granted in virtue of corresponding satisfaction. In the extra-sacramental satisfaction of the
remission of temporal punishments for sins in Indulgences, the Church offers to the Divine
Justice a substitute satisfaction - that is, the infinite satisfaction of Christ and the
superabundant satisfaction of the Saints. These satisfactions, in the case of the Saints,
exceeded the measure of their own sins and, together with the superabundant merits of
Christ, form the Church's treasury of merit, or treasury of satisfaction.
In the granting of an Indulgence, the Church appeals to the mercy of God, beseeching Him to
grant those members of the Mystical Body of Christ who fulfill the prescribed conditions, a
remission of their due punishments which have not yet been atoned for, in the virtue of the
superabundant satisfactions of Christ and the Saints. The prayer of the Church requires the
gracious acceptance of God, but in view of the position of the person granting the Indulgence
in the Mystical Body of Christ, a hearing can, with moral certainty, be counted on. [...]
Catholics believe that many of the faithful throughout the centuries - virgins, martyrs,
confessors, saints etc. - have performed penance's and good works far in excess of what was
due as temporal punishment for their own sins. Their merits, in union with the infinite merits of
Jesus Christ, form a "spiritual treasury" which the Church can draw upon to assist other
members of the Church in general or, in particular, pay the debt of temporal punishment both
for the living and the dead:
"I am now rejoicing in my sufferings for your sake, and in my flesh I am completing what is
lacking in Christ's afflictions for the sake of his body, that is, the church" (Col. 1:24); "For just
as the body is one and has many members, and all the members of the body, though many,
are one body, so it is with Christ;... If one member suffers, all suffer together with it; if one
member is honored, all rejoice together with it" (1 Cor. 12:12-26).
Every sin "harms" not only our relationship with God but also, our relationship with other
members of the "Body of Christ". Just as every good deed "honors" or "improves" the "Body
of Christ". Once we are forgiven by God, we are put back into a right relationship with Him, but
we still need to "heal" the "injury" to the "Body' of Believers. Therefore, by virtue of the
Communion of Saints the faithful can assist each other with their prayers, masses, almsgiving
to remit temporal punishment due in purgatory. Think of the life of someone like Padre Pio, a
man who might have never committed a serious sin, living a life of penance and suffering. All
these graces are in the treasury of the Church. "Strictly speaking, isolated prayer, or any
other activity, does not exist for the Christian, in so far as he can do or suffer nothing without
reference to other Christians;... every deed of each member affects for good or ill the whole
body,..." (FCD)
What is lacking in Christ's suffering?
Our complete will! Christ as Himself, lacks nothing. But as head of the Mystical Body of the
Church, what is lacking in His suffering is our complete will in union with His will! We are part
of the Mystical Body of Christ and as such, we need to be in complete accord with Christ, in
order to complete what is lacking in the sufferings of Christ. (Monsignor Harold F. Jordan)
Bearers of the Power of indulgence:
The practice of the power of Indulgence is not an act of the power of the priesthood, but of
the power of jurisdiction. The Pope, as possessor of the Supreme Power of Jurisdiction over
the whole Church, has an absolute, that is, an unlimited power of Indulgence. The bishops, by
virtue of their ordinary power, can grant Indulgences only to those subject to them, and within
the limited compass which is regulated by Canon Law. Cf. CIC 912, 274 n. 2, 349, Par. 2 n. 2.
Even Cardinals have only a limited power to grant Indulgences. CIC 239, Par. I n. 24.
The technical meaning of the word "grant'', when there is question of an Indulgence
applicable to the faithful departed, is that the Indulgence is offered to God by way of suffrage
and appeal.
An Indulgence cannot be gained for another living person. (FCD)
Division of Indulgences
Full is Plenary - Partial is - just that part of the remittance of punishment.
a.) According to the extent of the remission of the Punishment, Indulgences are divided into
Plenary Indulgences [...], and Partial Indulgences [...], according as the temporal punishments
are completely or only partially remitted. The measure of the remission of the punishment
depends on the approval of the Church: [...]. The periods of time customarily stipulated in the
case of Partial Indulgences signify that as many punishments for sins are remitted as would
have been expiated in the given time according to the norms of the old canonical penance. [...]
b.) According to the mode of their application, a division is made between Indulgences for the
living and for the dead. The granting of an Indulgence to the living faithful is accomplished by
absolution [...]. The Church has no jurisdiction over the dead in Purgatory; thus, Indulgences
cannot be applied directly to them through absolution, but only indirectly through intercession
[...], for which reason their operation is uncertain. The possibility of their application is
founded on the Communion of Saints. [...]
Historically it was only in the second half of the fifteenth century [...], that Indulgences for the
dead appear, although the Scholastic Theologians [13th century], had already affirmed the
possibility of Indulgences for the dead (suppl. 71, 10). (FCD)
[2 Mac. 12] v. 42, "and they turned to prayer, beseeching that the sin which had been
committed might be wholly blotted out." v. 43, "He also took up a collection, . . . , and sent it to
Jerusalem for a sin offering. . . .taking account the resurrection. v. 44, For if he were not
expecting those who had fallen to rise again, it would have been superfluous and foolish to
pray for the dead."
Here we have the basic idea of our present day "indulgence" for the souls in Purgatory.
First: we know that the souls are in an intermediate state because in hell there is no relief
[Dan. 12:2; Mt. 18:8] and in heaven there is no need for relief.
Second: we have intercessory prayer for the dead & a "collection" with the intent of the relief
of suffering for our dearly departed.
Communion of Saints -
Jesus said that he is the true vine, and we are the branches. When a Christian (one branch)
dies physically and is taken up into heaven (he might have to go through Purgatory first), he
isn't broken off the vine. He remains in Christ (Romans 8:38-39). The deceased Christian is
still united with the vine (Jesus) and with all the other branches (all other Christians, living or
dead). This communion of saints makes possible the sharing of spiritual things with other
Christians.
Bibliography
All Scripture is quoted from the Revised Standard Version - Catholic Edition - Ignatius Press,
unless otherwise noted.
Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, by Ludwig Ott, (FCD). The Doctrine of Indulgences
These are sources where I was unable to verify the "authority" of the teaching. For example:
many times I used an Internet source, that did not give references as to the source of their
teaching.
